Ritesh Sabharwal CFP®

W.M.W #47: India's BNPL Phantom Debt Crisis

Reading time: 5 minutes - May 9, 2026

↓

Hey Reader

Rahul is 23. Earns ₹35,000/month.

2 months back, he bought wireless earbuds (₹2,500), a weekend trip (₹4,200), sneakers (₹3,800), food deliveries (₹2,100), and an OTT subscription (₹1,500).

Total: ₹14,400; Paid upfront: ₹0
​He used Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) across 3 different apps. By month end, when he checked his bank statement with ₹12,000 left. He feels comfortable.

Then the auto-debits start.
​April 7: ₹833. April 10: ₹1,400. April 14: ₹950. April 18: ₹700. April 22: ₹600. Within 15 days, ₹4,483 vanishes.
​Rahul is confused. "Where did my money go?"

He forgot about the ₹14,400 BNPL debt because it was invisible.
​Not on his credit card. Not in his bank statement. Just scattered across 3 apps with different repayment dates.

This is phantom debt. Debt that doesn't feel real until the money disappears. And it's India's fastest-growing silent crisis.

The Numbers Behind the Crisis

India's BNPL market (Source)

• 2025: USD 24.86 billion
• 2026 projected: USD 30.45 billion - 22.5% annual growth
• 2031 projected: USD 62.61 billion

The market will more than double in 5 years.

But here's the scary part: More than 55% feel they spend more when using BNPL (Source)

Why? Because BNPL creates an illusion. Your brain registers "This costs ₹0 today." Your bank account registers "₹4,500 disappeared this week."

What is Phantom Debt?

Some economists use 'Phantom Debt' term to describe hidden, untracked BNPL debts that do not appear on standard credit reports.

Traditional credit card debt:

• One monthly statement
• Clear total: ₹25,000 outstanding
• Single payment date
• You know exactly what you owe

BNPL phantom debt:

• Scattered across multiple apps
• Different repayment dates (7th, 10th, 14th, 18th, 22nd etc)
• Each installment feels small (₹600, ₹800)
• No consolidated view

Result: You feel like you owe ₹3,000 when you actually owe ₹10,000.

Why BNPL Makes You Overspend

1. The Pain of Paying Disappears

Research (Prelec & Loewenstein) shows: Paying cash activates your brain's pain center.
​
Now, Credit cards reduce this pain but BNPL eliminates it entirely. When you split ₹3,000 into "3 easy payments of ₹1,000," your brain doesn't register losing ₹3,000. It registers ₹1,000 three times - and future payments always feel less painful.

2. Mental Accounting Errors

You use different BNPL apps for different categories:

• Platform 1 Pay Later = "shopping budget"
• Platform 2 BNPL = "food budget"
• Platform 3 BNPL = "travel budget"

Each feels isolated. Each ₹500-₹800 installment feels trivial.

But when 3 apps auto-debit in the same week, you're suddenly ₹2k-3k short.

3. Optimism Bias

You think: "Next month's salary will cover it."
​Reality: Rent increases. Medical emergency. Friend's wedding. Salary delayed.

Optimism crashes into reality. BNPL installments don't care.

Why Phantom Debt is More Dangerous Than Credit Cards

The killer difference: Credit cards reward on-time payments with better credit scores. BNPL only punishes. It rarely rewards.

RBI's 2025-26 Crackdown: What's Changing

BNPL operated in a gray zone. That's ending. Key Changes Under RBI's Digital Lending Directions, 2025:

1. BNPL is Now Classified as Credit Subject to full lending regulations.
​2. Mandatory KYC Full Aadhaar, income proof, bank statements required.
​3. Key Fact Statement Before Every Transaction Must show: Total amount, APR, repayment schedule, late fees, default consequences.
​4. No More Wallet-Based BNPL ICICI Bank discontinued PayLater on UPI in 2025. Paytm-style wallet BNPL banned.
​5. Direct Bank-to-Bank Flows Only No intermediaries. Full traceability.

What this means:
✅ More transparency, clearer terms
✅ Better consumer protection
✅ Harder approvals, stricter checks

Hidden Costs They Don't Tell You

Based on current 2026 guidelines, late fees for "Buy Now, Pay Later" (BNPL) apps are not always flat fees. They are often calculated as a percentage of the outstanding amount and increase based on the delay in payment. Here is a breakdown of the late fees and bounce charges as of May 2026 for 2 of the most used platforms.
​
1. LazyPay Charges (Source)

• Late Fee: Ranges from ₹50 to ₹590 depending on the outstanding amount. A penal interest of 3.25% per month (39% per annum) may also apply.
• Bounce Charge: ₹300 per instance if auto-pay fails due to insufficient balance.

2. Amazon Pay Later Charges (Source)

• Late Fee: For outstanding amounts (after the 5th of the month):
  • <= ₹200: 0
  • >₹200 <= ₹1,000: ₹125
  • >₹1,000 but <=₹2,500: ₹300
  • >₹2,500 but <=₹5,000: ₹350
  • >₹5,000 but <=₹10,000: ₹450
  • >₹10,000 & <= ₹20,000: ₹800
  • >₹20,000: ₹1,000
• GST: An additional 18% GST applies to late fees.
• Bounce Charge: Not explicitly listed as a flat fee, but late fees apply from the 7th or 11th of the month depending on the lender.

How to Protect Yourself

☐ Step 1: Audit Your BNPL Debt Now: Open every app. Note: Outstanding amount, due dates, installments. Create a sheet. Make phantom debt visible.

☐ Step 2: Use Only ONE BNPL App: Delete the rest. Easier to track. Less confusion.

☐ Step 3: 48-Hour Cooling-Off Rule: Before using BNPL, ask:

• Would I buy this if I had to pay cash today?
• Do I need this in 48 hours?

If NO → Don't use BNPL.

☐ Step 4: Build a ₹5,000-10,000 Auto-Debit Buffer: Keep this in your account always. BNPL safety net.

☐ Step 5: Check Credit Report Quarterly: Free reports: CIBIL, Experian. Check for missed payments you didn't know about.

When to Use BNPL (And When Not To)

✅ Use BNPL When:

1. You already have the money (using for convenience, not affordability)
​2. Essential purchase, bad timing (laptop broke, salary in 10 days)
​3. Buying from ONE platform only

❌ Avoid BNPL When:

1. Can't afford it today (₹5,000 won't feel cheaper as ₹1,667 × 3)
​2. Already using 3+ BNPL apps (phantom debt zone)
​3. Don't know total BNPL exposure (RED FLAG)
​4. Purchase is discretionary (wants, not needs)

The Bottom Line

By 2031, India's BNPL market will hit ₹5.25 lakh crores. ~55% of users admit overspending.

Why? Phantom debt doesn't feel real until it's too late.

Your brain sees: "₹0 today"
​Your bank sees: "₹10,000 gone"

RBI is tightening rules. But rules protect the system, not you.

You protect yourself by:

• Making phantom debt visible
• Limiting to one app
• Treating BNPL like credit, not magic
• Building auto-debit buffers
• Never using BNPL for what you can't afford today

BNPL is a tool. Tools can build or destroy.
The difference? Knowing when to use it and when to walk away. It's not free. It's deferred. And the bill always comes due.

The debt you can't see is the debt that destroys you.

P.S. I write every day to help you make smarter money decisions. Connect with me on LinkedIn👇.

​